Wayne Andres wrote:
> Okay. Here's the problemo. I'm not certain I fully understand the
> Orthodox doctrine regarding Christ's substitutionary death on the Cross.
> Let me approach this question by simply asking some questions:
> 1. Why did the Lord need to die?
> 2. How would the death of a "perfect man/God" satisfy God the Father? It
> sounds as though He is being appeased and I know that can't be the case.
> So...uh...why the shedding of blood? I know Scripture says, "Without the
> shedding of blood there is no remission of sins"...but why not? Why this
> particular way?
> --
> Wayne
> mailto:wayneand...@sprint.ca
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
--From the OCA Website---
Redemption
By Protopresbyter Thomas Hopko
And He was crucified for us under Pontius Pilate,
and suffered, and was buried.
Although Jesus did not sin and did not have to suffer
and die, he
voluntarily took upon himself the sins of the world and
voluntarily gave himself up to suffering and death for
the sake of
salvation. This was his task as the Messiah-Saviour:
The Spirit of the Lord is upon me to bring good
tidings to the afflicted ... to bind up the
broken-hearted, to proclaim liberty to the
captives, and the opening of the prison to those
who are bound ... to comfort all who mourn ... to
give them a garland instead of ashes, the oil of
gladness instead of mourning" (Isa 61:1-3).
And at the same time, Jesus had to do this as the
suffering
servant of Yahweh-God.
He was despised and rejected by men, a man of
sorrows, and acquainted with grief, and as one
from whom men hide their faces he was despised.
and we esteemed him not.
Surely he has borne our griefs and carried our
sorrows, yet we esteemed him stricken, smitten by
God and afflicted.
But he was wounded for our transgressions, he
was bruised for our iniquities, upon him was the
chastisement that made us whole, and by his
stripes [i.e., wounds] we are healed.
All we like sheep have gone astray; we have
turned everyone to his own way; and the Lord has
laid on him the iniquity of us all.
He was oppressed, and he was afflicted, yet he
opened not his mouth; like a lamb led to the
slaughter, and like a sheep that before his
shearers
is dumb, so he opened not his mouth.
By oppression and judgement he was taken away
... And they made his grave with the wicked, and
with a rich man in his death, although he had done
no violence, and there was no deceit in his mouth.
Yet it was the will of the Lord (Yahweh) to bruise
him; he has put him to grief; when he makes
himself an offering for sin, he shall see his
offspring, he shall prolong his days; the will of
the
Lord shall prosper in his hand; he shall see the
fruit
of the travail of his soul and be satisfied; by
his
knowledge shall the righteous one, my servant,
make many to be accounted righteous; and he
shall bear their iniquities.
Therefore I will divide him a portion with the
great
and he shall divide the spoil with the strong;
because he poured out his soul to death, and was
numbered with the transgressors; yet he bore the
sin of many [or the multitude] and made
intercession for the transgressors (Isa 53).
These words of the prophet Isaiah written centuries
before the
birth of Jesus tell the story of his Messianic mission.
It began
officially before the eyes of all in his baptism by
John in the
Jordan. By allowing himself to be baptized with the
sinners
though he had no sin, Jesus shows that he accepts his
calling to
be identified with the sinners: "the Beloved" of the
Father and
"the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world"
(Jn
1:29; Mt 3:17).
Jesus begins to teach, and on the very day and at that
very
moment when his disciples first confess him to be the
Messiah,
"the Christ, the Son of the Living God," Jesus tells
immediately
of his mission to "go to Jerusalem and suffer many
things ... and
be killed, and on the third day be raised" (Mt
16:16-23; Mk
8:29-33). The apostles are greatly upset by this. Jesus
then
immediately shows them his divinity by being
transfigured
before them in divine glory on the mountain in the
presence of
Moses and Elijah. He then tells them once more: "The
Son of
Man is to be delivered into the hands of men, and they
will kill
him, and he will be raised on the third day" (Mt
17:1-23; Mk
9:1-9).
The powers of evil multiplied against Christ at the
end: "The
kings of the earth counsel together against the Lord
and His
Christ" (Ps 2:2). They were looking for causes to kill
him. The
formal reason was blasphemy, "because you, being a man,
make yourself God" (Jn 10:31-38). Yet the deep reasons
were
more personal: Jesus told men the truth and revealed
their
stubbornness, foolishness, hypocrisy, and sin. For this
reason
every sinner, hardened in his sins and refusing to
repent, wishes
and causes the crucifixion of Christ.
The death of Jesus came at the hands of the religious
and
political leaders of his time, with the approval of the
masses:
when Caiaphas was high priest, "under Pontius Pilate."
He was
"crucified for us ... and suffered and was buried" in
order to be
with us in our sufferings and death which we brought
upon
ourselves because of our sins: "for the wages of sin
are death"
(Rom 6:23). In this sense the Apostle Paul writes of
Jesus that
"having become a curse for us" (Gal 3:13), "for our
sake he
(God the Father) made him to be sin who knew no sin, so
that
in him we might become the righteousness of God" (2 Cor
5:21).
The sufferings and death of Christ in obedience to the
Father
reveals the super-abundant divine love of God for his
creation.
For when all was sinful, cursed, and dead, Christ
became sin, a
curse, and dead for us -- though he himself never
ceased to be
the righteousness and blessedness and life of God
Himself. It is
to this depth, of which lower and more base cannot be
discovered or imagined, that Christ has humiliated
himself "for
us men and for our salvation." For being God, he became
man;
and being man, he became a slave; and being a slave, he
became dead and not only dead, but dead on a cross.
From
this deepest degradation of God flows the eternal
exaltation of
man. This is the pivotal doctrine of the Orthodox
Christian faith,
expressed over and again in many ways throughout the
history
of the Orthodox Church. It is the doctrine of the
atonement --
for we are made to be "at one" with God. It is the
doctrine of
redemption -- for we are redeemed, i.e., "bought with a
price," the great price of the blood of God (Acts
20:28; 1 Cor
6:20).
Have this mind among yourselves which you have
in Christ Jesus who, though He was in the form of
God, did not count equality with God a thing to be
grasped, but emptied Himself, taking the form of a
servant [slave], being born in the likeness of
men.
And being found in human form, He humbled
Himself and became obedient unto death, even
death on a cross. Therefore God has highly
exalted Him and bestowed on Him the name
which is above every name, that at the name of
Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on
earth and under the earth, and every tongue
confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of
God the Father (Phil 2:5-11).
In contemplating the saving and redeeming action of
Christ, it
has become traditional to emphasize three aspects which
in
reality are not divided, and cannot be; but which in
theory (i.e.,
in the vision of Christ's being.and activity as the
Saviour of the
world) may be distinguished. The first of these three
aspects of
the redeeming work of Christ is the fact that Jesus
saves
mankind by providing the perfect image and example of
human
life as filled with the grace and power of God.
Jesus, the Perfect Image of Human
Life
Christ is the incarnate Word of God. He is the Teacher
and
Master sent by God to the world. He is the embodiment
of
God Himself in human form. He is "the image of the
invisible
God" (Col 1:15). In Him "the fullness of divinity
dwells bodily"
(Col 2:9). The person who sees Jesus sees God the
Father (Jn
14:9). He is the "reflection of the glory of God and
the express
image of His person" (Heb 1:3). He is the "light of the
world"
who "enlightens every man...coming into the world" (Jn
8:12,
1:9). To be saved by Jesus Christ is first of all to be
enlightened
by Him; to see Him as the Light, and to see all things
in the light
of Him. It is to know Him as "the Truth" (Jn 14:6); and
to
know the truth in Him.
And you will know the truth and the truth will
make you free (Jn 8:31).
When one is saved by God in Christ one comes to the
knowledge of the truth, fulfilling God's desire for His
creatures,
for "God our Saviour ... desires all men to be saved
and to
come to the knowledge of the truth" (1 Tim 2:4). In
saving
God's world, Jesus Christ enlightens God's creatures by
the
Holy Spirit, the Spirit of God who is the Spirit of
Truth who
proceeds from the Father and is sent into the world
through
Christ.
If you love Me, you will keep My
commandments. And I will pray the Father, and
He will give you another Counselor, to be with
you forever, even the Spirit of Truth, whom the
world cannot receive, because it neither sees Him
nor knows Him; you know Him, for He dwells
with you, and will be in you (Jn 14:15-17).
But the Counselor, the Holy Spirit, whom the
Father will send in My name, He will teach you all
things, and bring to your remembrance all that I
have said to you ... (Jn 15:26).
When the Spirit of Truth comes, He will guide you
into all the truth ... (Jn 16:13).
The first aspect of salvation in Christ, therefore, is
to be
enlightened by Him and to know the truth about God and
man
by the guidance of the Holy Spirit, the Spirit of
Truth, which
God gives through Him to those who believe. This is
witnessed
to in the apostolic writings of Saints John and Paul:
Now we have received not the spirit of the world,
but the Spirit which is from God, that we might
understand the gifts bestowed on us by God. And
we impart this in words not taught by human
wisdom, but taught by the Spirit, interpreting
spiritual truths to those who possess the Spirit.
[...] For who has known the mind of the Lord so
as to instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ
(1 Cor 2:13-16).
For [God] has made known to us in all wisdom
and insight the mystery of His will, according to
His purpose which He set forth in Christ as a plan
for the fullness of time, to unite all things in
Him,
things in heaven and things on earth. [...] To me
...
this grace was given ... to make all men see what
is the plan of the mystery hidden for ages in God
... that through the church the manifold wisdom of
God might now be made known ... (Eph 1:8-10;
3:9).
For I want ... that their hearts may be encouraged
as they are knit together in love, to have all the
riches of assured understanding and the
knowledge of God's mystery in Christ, in whom
are hid all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge
(Col 2:1-3).
But you have been anointed by the Holy One, and
you know all things I write to you, not because
you do not know the truth, but because you know
it, and know that no lie is of the truth. [...]
but the
anointing which you received from Him abides in
you, and you have no need that any one should
teach you; as His anointing teaches you about
everything, and is true and is no lie, just as it
has
taught you, abide in Him. [...] And by this we
know that He abides in us, by the Spirit which He
has given to us (1 Jn 2:20-27; 3:24).
The first aspect of man's salvation by God in Christ
is,
therefore, the ability and power to see, to know, to
believe and
to love the truth of God in Christ, who is the Truth,
by the Spirit
of Truth. It is the gift of knowledge and wisdom, of
illumination
and enlightenment, it is the condition of being "taught
by God"
as foretold by the prophets and fulfilled by Christ
(Isa 54:13;
Jer 31:33-34; Jn 6:45). Thus, in the Orthodox Church,
the
entrance into the saving life of the Church through
baptism and
chrismation is called "holy illumination."
For it is God who said, "Let light shine out of
darkness," who has shone in our hearts to give the
light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the
face of Christ (2 Cor 4:6).
Jesus, the Reconciler of Man with
God
The second aspect of Christ's one, indivisible act of
salvation of
man and his world is the accomplishment of man's
reconciliation
with God the Father through the forgiveness of sins.
This is the
redemption and atonement strictly speaking, the release
from
sins, and the punishment due to sins; the being made
"at one"
with God.
While we were yet helpless, at the right time
Christ died for the ungodly. Why, one will hardly
die for a righteous man -- though perhaps for a
good man one will dare even to die. But God
shows His love for us in that while we were yet
sinners Christ died for us. Since therefore we are
now made righteous by His blood, much more
shall we be saved by Him from the wrath of God.
For if while we were enemies we were reconciled
to God by the death of His Son, much more, now
that we are reconciled, shall we be saved by His
life. Not only so, but we also rejoice in God
through our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom we
have now received our reconciliation (Rom
5:6-11).
Therefore if anyone is in Christ, he is a new
creation; the old has passed away, behold, the
new has come. All this is from God, who through
Christ reconciled us to Himself and gave us the
ministry of reconciliation; that is, God was in
Christ reconciling the world to Himself, not
counting their trespasses against them, and
entrusting to us the message of reconciliation (2
Cor 5:17-19).
The forgiveness of sins is one of the signs of the
coming of the
Christ, the Messiah, as foretold in the Old Testament:
... they shall all know me, from the least to the
greatest, says the Lord; for I will forgive their
iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more
(Jer
31:34).
Christ is the Lamb of God who takes away the sins of
the
world, the Lamb that is slain that through Him all sins
might be
forgiven. He is also the great high priest, who offers
the perfect
sacrifice by which man is purged from his sins and
cleansed
from his iniquities. Jesus offers, as high priest, the
perfect
sacrifice of His own very life, His own body, as the
Lamb of
God, upon the tree of the cross.
For to this you have been called, because Christ
suffered for you, leaving you an example that you
should follow in His steps. He committed no sin;
no guile was found on His lips. When He was
reviled, He did not revile in return; when He
suffered, He did not threaten; but He trusted to
Him who judges justly. He Himself bore our sins
in His body on the tree, that we might die to sin
and live to righteousness. By His wounds you
have been healed. For you were straying like
sheep, but have now returned to the Pastor and
Bishop of your souls (1 Pet 2:22-25).
The high-priestly offering and sacrifice of the Son of
God to His
eternal Father is described in great detail in the
Letter to the
Hebrews in the New Testament scriptures.
In the days of His flesh, Jesus offered up prayers
and supplications, with loud cries and tears, to
Him who was able to save Him from death, and
He was heard for His godly fear. Although He
was a Son, He learned obedience through what
He suffered, and being made perfect, He became
the source of eternal salvation to all who obey
Him, being designated a high priest by God,
according to the order of Melchizedek (Heb
5:7-10).
But when Christ appeared as a high priest of the
good things that have come ... He entered once
for all into the Holy Place [not made by hands,
i.e., the Presence of God] taking ... His own
blood, thus securing an eternal redemption. For if
the sprinkling of defiled persons with the blood
of
goats and bulls and with the ashes of a heifer
sanctifies for the purification of the flesh, how
much more shall the blood of Christ who through
the eternal Spirit offered Himself without blemish
to God, purify your conscience from dead works
to serve the living God. Therefore, He is the
mediator of a new covenant, so that those who
are called may receive the promised eternal
inheritance, since a death has occurred which
redeems them from the transgressions under the
first covenant (Heb 9:11-15).
According to the scriptures, man's sins and the sins of
the whole
world are forgiven and pardoned by the sacrifice of
Christ, by
the offering of His life -- His body and His blood,
which is the
"blood of God" (Acts 20:28) -- upon the cross. This is
the
"redemption," the "ransom," the "expiation," the
"propitiation"
spoken about in the scriptures which had to be made so
that
man could be "at one" with God. Christ "paid the price"
which
was necessary to be paid for the world to be pardoned
and
cleansed of all iniquities and sins (1 Cor 6:20; 7:23).
In the history of Christian doctrine there has been
great debate
over the question of to whom Christ "pays the price"
for the
ransom of the world and the salvation of mankind. Some
have
said that the "payment" was made to the devil. This is
the view
that the devil received certain "rights" over man and
his world
because of man's sin. In his rebellion against God, man
"sold
himself to the devil" thus allowing the Evil One to
become the
"prince of this world" (Jn 12:31). Christ comes to pay
the debt
to the devil and to release man from his control by
sacrificing
Himself upon the cross.
Others say that Christ's "payment" on behalf of man had
to be
made to God the Father. This is the view which
interprets
Christ's sacrificial death on the cross as the proper
punishment
that had to be paid to satisfy God's wrath over the
human race.
God was insulted by man's sin. His law was broken and
His
righteousness was offended. Man had to pay the penalty
for his
sin by offering the proper punishment. But no amount of
human
punishment could satisfy God's justice because God's
justice is
divine. Thus the Son of God had to be born into the
world and
receive the punishment that was rightly to be placed on
men. He
had to die in order for God to receive proper
satisfaction for
man's offenses against Him. Christ substituted Himself
on our
behalf and died for our sins, offering His blood as the
satisfying
sacrifice for the sins of the world. By dying on the
cross in place
of sinful man, Christ pays the full and total payment
for man's
sins. God's wrath is removed. Man's insult is punished.
The
world is reconciled with its Creator.
Commenting on this question about to whom Christ "pays
the
price" for man's salvation, St. Gregory the Theologian
in the
fourth century wrote the following in his second Easter
Oration:
Now we are to examine another fact and dogma,
neglected by most people, but in my judgment
well worth enquiring into. To whom was that
Blood offered that was shed for us, and why was
It shed? I mean the precious and famous Blood of
our God and High Priest and Sacrifice.
We were detained in bondage by the Evil One,
sold under sin, and receiving pleasure in exchange
for wickedness. Now, since a ransom belongs
only to him who holds in bondage, I ask to whom
was this offered, and for what cause?
If to the Evil One, fie upon the outrage! If the
robber receives ransom, not only from God, but a
ransom which consists of God Himself, and has
such an illustrious payment for his tyranny, then
it
would have been right for him to have left us
alone
altogether!
But if to God the Father, I ask first, how? For it
was not by Him that we were being oppressed.
And next, on what principle did the Blood of His
only-begotten Son delight the Father, who would
not receive even Isaac, when he was being
sacrificed by his father, [Abraham,] but changed
the sacrifice by putting a ram in the place of the
human victim? (See Gen 22).
Is it not evident that the Father accepts Him, but
neither asked for Him nor demanded Him; but on
account of the incarnation, and because Humanity
must be sanctified by the Humanity of God, that
He might deliver us Himself, and overcome the
tyrant (i.e., the devil) and draw us to Himself by
the mediation of His Son who also arranged this to
the honor of the Father, whom it is manifest He
obeys in all things.
In Orthodox theology generally it can be said that the
language
of "payment" and "ransom" is rather understood as a
metaphorical and symbolical way of saying that Christ
has done
all things necessary to save and redeem mankind
enslaved to
the devil, sin and death, and under the wrath of God.
He "paid
the price," not in some legalistic or juridical or
economic
meaning. He "paid the price" not to the devil whose
rights over
man were won by deceit and tyranny. He "paid the price"
not to
God the Father in the sense that God delights in His
sufferings
and received "satisfaction" from His creatures in Him.
He "paid
the price" rather, we might say, to Reality Itself. He
"paid the
price" to create the conditions in and through which
man might
receive the forgiveness of sins and eternal life by
dying and
rising again in Him to newness of life (See Rom 5-8;
Gal 2-4).
By dying on the cross and rising from the dead, Jesus
Christ
cleansed the world from evil and sin. He defeated the
devil "in
his own territory" and on "his own terms." The "wages
of sin is
death" (Rom 6:23). So the Son of God became man and
took
upon Himself the sins of the world and died a voluntary
death.
By His sinless and innocent death accomplished entirely
by His
free will -- and not by physical, moral, or juridical
necessity --
He made death to die and to become itself the source
and the
way into life eternal. This is what the Church sings on
the feast
of the Resurrection, the New Passover in Christ, the
new
Paschal Lamb, who is risen from the dead:
Christ is risen from the dead!
Trampling down death by death!
And upon those in the tombs bestowing life!
(Easter Troparion)
And this is how the Church prays at the divine liturgy
of Saint
Basil the Great:
He was God before the ages, yet He appeared on
earth and lived among men, becoming incarnate of
a holy Virgin;
He emptied Himself, taking the form of a servant,
being likened to the body of our lowliness, that
He
might liken us to the image of His Glory.
For as by man sin entered into the world, and
death by sin, so it pleased Thine Only-begotten
Son, who was in the bosom of Thee, the God and
Father, who was born of a woman, the holy
Theotokos and ever-virgin Mary, who was born
under the law to condemn sin in His flesh, so that
those who were dead in Adam might be made
alive in Thy Christ Himself.
He lived in this world and gave commandments of
salvation; releasing us from the delusions of
idolatry, He brought us to knowledge of Thee, the
true God and Father. He obtained us for His own
chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation.
Having cleansed us in water, and sanctified us
with
the Holy Spirit, He gave Himself as a ransom to
death, in which we were held captive, sold under
sin.
Descending through the cross into Sheol -- that
He might fill all things with Himself -- He loosed
the pangs of death. He arose on the third day,
having made for all flesh a path to the
resurrection
from the dead, since it was not possible for the
Author of Life to be a victim of corruption.
So He became the first-fruits of those who have
fallen asleep, the first-born of the dead, that He
might be Himself truly the first in all things ...
(Eucharistic Prayer of the Liturgy of St. Basil)
Jesus, the Destroyer of Death
The third and final aspect of the saving and redeeming
action of
Christ, therefore, is the deepest and most
comprehensive. It is
the destruction of death by Christ's own death. It is
the
transformation of death itself into an act of life. It
is the
recreation of Sheol -- the spiritual condition of being
dead --
into the paradise of God. Thus, in and through the
death of
Jesus Christ, death is made to die. In Him, who is the
Resurrection and the Life, man cannot die, but lives
forever with
God.
Truly, truly I say to you, he who hears my word
and believes in Him who sent me has eternal life;
he does not come into judgment, but has passed
from death into life (Jn 5:24).
"I am the Resurrection and the Life! He who
believes in me, though he die, yet shall he live,
and
whoever lives and believes in me shall never die"
(Jn 11:25-26).
It is Christ Jesus who died, yes, who was raised
from the dead, who is at the right hand of God,
who indeed intercedes for us! Who shall separate
us from the love of Christ? [...] For I am sure
that
neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor
principalities, nor things present, nor things to
come, nor powers, nor height, nor depth, nor
anything else in all creation will be able to
separate
us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord
(Rom 8:34-39).
For in Him the whole fullness of divinity dwells
bodily, and you have come to fullness of life in
Him ... and you were buried with Him in baptism,
in which you were also raised with Him through
faith in the working of God who raised Him from
the dead. And you were dead in trespasses ...
God made alive together with Him, having
forgiven us all our trespasses, having cancelled
the
bond which stood against us with its legal
demands; this He set aside, nailing it to the
cross.
He disarmed the [demonic] principalities and
powers and made a public example of them,
triumphing over them ... for you have died, and
your life is hid with Christ in God (Col 2:9 ff).
This is the doctrine of the New Testament scriptures,
repeated
over and again in many ways in the tradition of the
Church: in its
sacraments, hymnology, theology, iconography. Christ's
victory
over death is man's release from sins and man's victory
over
enslavement to the devil because in and through
Christ's death
man dies and is born again to eternal life. In his
death sins are
no longer counted. In his death the devil no longer
holds him. In
his death he is born again to newness of life and is
liberated
from all that is evil, false, demonic, and sinful. In a
word, he is
freed from all that is dead by dying and rising again
in and with
Jesus.
But we see Jesus, who for a little while was made
lower than the angels, crowned with glory and
honor because of the suffering of death, so that
by
the grace of God He might taste death for every
one. [...] Since therefore the children share in
flesh
and blood, He Himself likewise partook of the
same nature, that through death He might destroy
him who has the power of death, that is, the
devil,
and deliver all those who through fear of death
were subject to lifelong bondage (Heb 2:9-15).
But in fact Christ has been raised from the dead,
the first-fruits of those who have fallen asleep.
For
as by a man came death, by a Man has come also
the resurrection of the dead. For as in Adam all
die, so also in Christ shall all be made alive.
[...]
The sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is
the law. But thanks be to God who gives us the
victory through our Lord Jesus Christ (1 Cor
15:20ff; 56-57).